I am still not sure which version was the best but I used
Chocolate rice cake
There are many alternatives
For antlers : curly wherly, choc fingers
Nose: strawberries, wine gums
Eyes: marshmallows, grapes, banana
Mouth: raisins, liquorice ,
Face: chocolate biscuit , pancake
Dylan enjoyed this, wasn't sure if he would like the rice cake but he did.
We can do this again as a cooking/ following instructions activity.